News ‘American Idol’ runner-up Willie Spence dies after a car crash at 23: ‘I’m in shock’ October 12, 2022 Elise Brisco, USA TODAY Comments Off on ‘American Idol’ runner-up Willie Spence dies after a car crash at 23: ‘I’m in shock’ Willie Spence, who finished 2021's Season 19 of "American Idol" in second place with "undeniable" talent, died Oct. 11 in a car crash. He was 23.